With React Server Components getting more traction, this idea of each component being able to fetch its own data seems to getting more popular rather than data-fetching being purely route-based.

In Remix-land, you’ve had a talk about “full-stack components” with a similar concept where a “resource route” can have no default exports but still export a loader and a React component in order to have a reusable component with its own data fetching.

It seems there might be differences between React Server Components and these “full-stack components” though, especially in that Server Components don’t need to be defined in routes but Remix full-stack components do.

Firstly, how are the two approaches different?

I ask, because I know Remix is working on implementing Server Components without the foot-guns, so curious what how the mental model would change in the future.

You, also said that it isn’t a good practice to get into to commonly import components from other routes.

My second question is why is it not a good practice, and can you give examples for cases where it would or wouldn’t make sense to import full-stack components from other routes?

Thank you!

• Full Stack Components

With React Server Components getting more traction, this idea of each component being able to fetch its own data seems to getting more popular rather than data-fetching being purely route-based.

In Remix-land, you’ve had a talk about “full-stack components” with a similar concept where a “resource route” can have no default exports but still export a loader and a React component in order to have a reusable component with its own data fetching.

It seems there might be differences between React Server Components and these “full-stack components” though, especially in that Server Components don’t need to be defined in routes but Remix full-stack components do.

Firstly, how are the two approaches different?

I ask, because I know Remix is working on implementing Server Components without the foot-guns, so curious what how the mental model would change in the future.

You, also said that it isn’t a good practice to get into to commonly import components from other routes.

My second question is why is it not a good practice, and can you give examples for cases where it would or wouldn’t make sense to import full-stack components from other routes?

Thank you!

• Full Stack Components

With React Server Components getting more traction, this idea of each component being able to fetch its own data seems to getting more popular rather than data-fetching being purely route-based.

In Remix-land, you’ve had a talk about “full-stack components” with a similar concept where a “resource route” can have no default exports but still export a loader and a React component in order to have a reusable component with its own data fetching.

It seems there might be differences between React Server Components and these “full-stack components” though, especially in that Server Components don’t need to be defined in routes but Remix full-stack components do.

Firstly, how are the two approaches different?

I ask, because I know Remix is working on implementing Server Components without the foot-guns, so curious what how the mental model would change in the future.

You, also said that it isn’t a good practice to get into to commonly import components from other routes.

My second question is why is it not a good practice, and can you give examples for cases where it would or wouldn’t make sense to import full-stack components from other routes?

Thank you!

• Full Stack Components

With React Server Components getting more traction, this idea of each component being able to fetch its own data seems to getting more popular rather than data-fetching being purely route-based.

In Remix-land, you’ve had a talk about “full-stack components” with a similar concept where a “resource route” can have no default exports but still export a loader and a React component in order to have a reusable component with its own data fetching.

It seems there might be differences between React Server Components and these “full-stack components” though, especially in that Server Components don’t need to be defined in routes but Remix full-stack components do.

Firstly, how are the two approaches different?

I ask, because I know Remix is working on implementing Server Components without the foot-guns, so curious what how the mental model would change in the future.

You, also said that it isn’t a good practice to get into to commonly import components from other routes.

My second question is why is it not a good practice, and can you give examples for cases where it would or wouldn’t make sense to import full-stack components from other routes?

Thank you!

• Full Stack Components